16 total reviews
Wedding Date: 7/6/2015
I can't express enough how much we loved our cake! There was nothing I would change about the taste, cost, or overall experience with Colleen.
We received many compliments from our guests on how wonderful the cake tasted. Many of them said it was the best wedding cake they have ever had!
My husband and I would recommend Colleen's Cakes to anyone wanting an amazing, absolutely delicious tasting and beautifully decorated cake. Thank you Colleen!
Wedding Date: 8/3/2013
My cake was absolutely beautiful and SO tasty!! Everyone loved it!! She is the sweetest person and so easy to work with!! You don't want to use any one else!!
Wedding Date: 9/20/2014
Colleen was such a joy to work with. She works out of her home by appointment and warmly welcomes you in for the tasting. And the cake-- some of the most delicious flavors I've ever tasted. I have a major sweet tooth and don't waste my time on anything that isn't incredible. I wanted three things for my wedding: fabulous pictures, a killer dress, and a delicious cake. With all the flavor choices and great customer service, Colleen went above and beyond my hopes.
Wedding Date: 8/30/2014
It was a pleasure to work with Colleen. She lets you sample all 15 or so flavors when you visit her. Each flavor is exceptional, but she still allows you to customize flavors. She also includes a free top layer to save for after the wedding or as an anniversary cake. Our guests absolutely loved it and wanted to try every flavor we got (white chocolate mousse, pink raspberry champagne, lemon blueberry, and chocolate turtle). Not to mention, the cakes turned out beautifully. I would highly recommend her!
Wedding Date: 3/15/2014
She was great from the cake sampling to our wedding day. She has a lovely work space and is very professional. She baked cupcakes overthink she offered...they were all delicious. My cake was just as I described and had agreed upon and tasted just as I remembered.
Wedding Date: 6/8/2013
OMG!! My wedding cakes were soooo goood that people repeated, and there was nothing, absolutely nothing left:-)!! I used to think that wedding cakes were the worse part of a wedding, found them always, dry, plain, bland and blah... Then I tried Colleen cakes. These are by far the best wedding cake I have ever had!! I went to different places for tasting, and they usually give you 4 different flavors to try. When I went to Colleen's she received us with somewhere between 16-20 cake flavors!!! They were all excellent, fresh, with fresh ingredients, just delicious!!! We had really hard time to choose our flavors, because it was a little too much to have a 20 tiers cake;-). Let me say this, I don't like chocolate at all, and this baker somehow made chocolate cakes for the tasting that I truly enjoyed. In addition to that, all the other bakers gave me hard time regarding the design and colors I chose for my cake (tiffany blue and red), saying that the red would bleed on the blue. Colleen was the only one that reassured me my design was doable, and that I had nothing to worry about my red bleeding. Anyways, after we chose her, the thing I was looking forward the most, on my wedding (other than saying I do) was the cake. And my big day came, my cake design was exactly as I requested, and the red stayed exactly where it was supposed to be. And just when I thought that it couldn't be any better, we cut the cake and it tasted even better than I remembered. All flavors were magnificent. People were telling me they have never had a more delicious wedding cake in their lives. In a blink, my cake was gone. Everybody loved it!!
Wedding Date: 2/22/2013
Colleen's Cakes was recommended through our venue, so we decided to meet with her for a consult appointment. During our consult, she had prepared for us 12 different individual GOURMET cupcakes of each and every flavor that she offered. Let me just say her cakes are amazing!!! So during our consult, we literally work out the details for both the bride and groom's cakes, and that was it! Her pricing was great! She was so easy to work with, and she knew exactly what we wanted. Best thing of all...we only met with her once, and then we didn't hear from her again until the wedding day!!! Yes, she was the only vendor that we didn't have to follow up with on a regular basis, and the end results were simply GREAT!!!
Wedding Date: 1/26/2013
Seriously, I think that Colleen makes the best cake I've ever tasted. Our guests went on and on about how amazing the cake was. Colleen worked with our budget and made the best cake! We had four different layers of cake and every layer was delightful. For the bride and groom, she made us cupcakes in all the different layer flavors for us to take back to our hotel. That was a nice touch! I will definitely be ordering other cakes from Colleen! You should too!
Wedding Date: 9/8/2012
Colleen created our wedding cakes a few months ago and they were great, tasted awesome. I had guests tell me it was the best cake they had ever had. Highly recommend Colleens Cakes!
Wedding Date: 8/5/2012
I don't know where to start! THE GROOM'S CAKE WAS AMAZING! Colleen was one of my top vendors, I will be using her again. The cake was extremely moist and the next day it just got better!
Her customer services was great as well!
Wedding Date: 5/27/2012
ABSOLUTELY AMAZING!! Our cakes are still being talked about 2 weeks after the wedding! We even got Colleen to make us cupcakes for our rehearsal dinner. Colleen is very professional and all of her cakes speak for themselves! All our cakes and cupcakes were fresh, beautiful, and delicious! We are even asking her to make a smaller version of our groom's cake just for us and our family since we weren't able to have any at our wedding! Can't wait! :-)
Wedding Date: 1/7/2012
Our cake was SO great! Not only that, but we really enjoyed meeting Colleen and she definitely delivered the best product possible. We had both a wedding cake or "bride's cake" and a groom's cake. They were both outrageously delicious and people went on and on talking about how delicious and beautiful they were. We had 4 flavors total between the two and they all tasted SO good. She was also the best price per serving we could find. On top of everything else that was wonderful, she also gave us a separate cake top of the flavor we wanted for the cake we would save, so the church could cut the top layer and it was no problem :) We would DEFINITELY use Colleen again!
Wedding Date: 9/4/2011
Ok, so the most important thing about any cake to me is taste, and on that front, Colleen is a 10. The amazing thing is she actually makes beautifully decorated cakes as well.
Wedding Date: 6/26/2011
If you are looking for a wedding cake that is as beautiful as it is delicious, you've got to use Colleen! Our cake was perfect! I gave her a picture of a cake I liked. and she duplicated it perfectly! She offers lots of different kinds of flavors, so we got to pick what we liked. We had 4 tiers, and did a different flavor for each one. The cake was incredible! Our wedding guests were raving about it!
Wedding Date: 4/17/2010
Colleen is amazing. Not only does she offer a wide variety of flavor choices, she also does the same recipes in gluten-free versions. She is willing to design anything you can dream up and her cake tastes SO GOOD! She did a four tier cake for our wedding that tons of guests just raved about. She has a standard per slice pricing that does not increase if you want to add extra flavors or anything. She even threw in a separate topper in a different flavor and a small birthday cake for my little cousin at no extra charge. Colleen will be a regular vendor for myself and my family for the rest of our lives!
Wedding Date: 12/11/2009
Colleen was recommended to me by a friend and I am so glad. She was so sweet and accommodating and her cakes taste amazing! Definitely use her for your cake lady. You will not regret it!
ColleensCakes - Elegant Cakes for Elegant Events.
Colleens Cakes specializes in custom wedding cakes, grooms cakes and celebration cakes. All of our cakes are individually designed for each client and are skillfully and imaginatively brought to life by one truly talented baker, Colleen.
awards and affiliations
- The Knot Best Of Weddings 2013
- The Knot Best Of Weddings 2012
- The Knot Best Of Weddings 2011